Blog Single

Introduction

Over the last few years, trade tensions between the United States and Canada have ebbed and flowed. With the prospect of new tariffs looming, many are asking: Is this time different? Before diving into the reasons why we might be facing a new reality, let’s take a quick look at how currency fluctuations played out during the 2018–2020 tariff period—setting the stage for the challenges and uncertainties ahead.

A Quick Timeline of the USD/CAD Exchange Rate (2018–2020)

• January 2018: 1 CAD ≈ 0.80 USD – Pre-announcement environment; trade tensions had yet to escalate.
• March 2018: 1 CAD ≈ 0.78 USD – U.S. announces tariffs on steel & aluminum; markets start reacting, CAD begins to dip.
• June 2018: 1 CAD ≈ 0.76 USD – Tariffs imposed; Canada retaliates. Cross-border trade becomes more expensive, and CAD weakens further.
• December 2018: 1 CAD ≈ 0.74 USD – Heightened trade pressures keep currency under strain, as uncertainty mounts.
• Mid-2019: 1 CAD ≈ 0.75 USD – Partial discussions of tariff relief; slight recovery for the CAD.
• January 2020: 1 CAD ≈ 0.77 USD – Relative stabilization before COVID-19 disruptions.
• March–June 2020: 1 CAD ≈ 0.73–0.74 USD – Pandemic outbreak layered onto lingering tariff issues, adding extra volatility.
• December 2020: 1 CAD ≈ 0.78 USD – Phase-one trade deals and partial rollbacks help the CAD regain some ground.

Why Currency Matters

1. Import/Export Costs: A weaker Canadian dollar (CAD) can help exporters temporarily, but it makes importing machinery, raw materials, and consumer goods more expensive.
2. Purchasing Power & Inflation: If the CAD remains weak, Canadian businesses and consumers see higher costs, potentially fueling inflation.
3. Investment Decisions: Exchange rate volatility makes foreign investors cautious—Canada may appear riskier, affecting capital inflows.
4. Confidence & Sentiment: Currency trends often reflect broader economic health; a consistently weak CAD can signal underlying vulnerabilities.

Overall, currency fluctuations are not just numbers on a chart—they have real-world implications for pricing, revenue, investments, and everyday consumer costs.

What’s Different This Time?

During the 2018–2020 tariff clash, we saw a back-and-forth standoff with periodic negotiations, rollbacks, and a final semblance of relief. Now, with talk of renewed tariffs on Canada (and Mexico) by President Trump, here’s what stands out as significantly different in 2025:

1. Stronger Mandate, Stronger Resolve
   President Trump, having secured a second term with broader support among trade hawks, is seen as more emboldened than ever. This reduces the likelihood of quick compromises or internal pushback. If tariffs begin, they may be tougher, last longer, and be less open to negotiation.
2. Canada’s Political Challenges & Weaker Economy
   Canada currently faces internal political disputes and economic strains—ranging from high consumer debt to questions around energy policy. With provincial-federal tensions and slower growth, the government is less agile in responding to sudden tariff measures. A weaker overall economy means Canadian businesses may have fewer buffers to absorb new trade shocks.
3. Diminished Global Standing
   While Canada once had a strong international reputation and a track record of successful trade diplomacy, recent diplomatic setbacks and stagnating global alliances have eroded that standing. In the past, Canada could rally broader support or leverage international goodwill to counterbalance U.S. moves. This time, it may find fewer allies willing to intervene or push for quick resolutions.
4. The Covid Diversion
   During the last major wave of U.S.-Canada tariff tensions, the sudden onset of the COVID-19 pandemic effectively shifted global priorities Governments around the world diverted their attention to managing a rapidly unfolding health crisis, implementing lockdowns, and rolling out emergency financial relief. In many cases, trade disputes took a temporary back seat, giving businesses a brief respite from escalating tariffs—but also adding a new layer of complexity through supply chain disruptions, plummeting demand, and widespread economic uncertainty that redefined what “crisis” meant on a global scale.

Where Does This Leave Us?

In short, renewed tariffs could hit Canada—and cross-border businesses—harder than before. With a stronger push from the U.S. side, a Canadian government navigating internal issues, and a less sympathetic global stage, the playbook from 2018–2020 may no longer apply.

But is this truly a crisis, or could it become a catalyst for deeper strategic change? Will it change the Canadian business mindset? In the next posts of this series, we’ll explore all this including pragmatic ways to shore up finances (from cash flow management to tax strategies) and then dive into innovative, lean approaches that might help businesses pivot or even thrive in this turbulent environment.

For now, we’ll leave the question open: Is this time different? If history is any indication, the stakes are higher, and the path to resolution could be more complex. The question remains—will businesses step up and adapt, or will they be caught off-guard by a new wave of uncertainty?

Final Note

This blog serves as a kick-off to our three-part series. In our next post, we’ll move from the macro picture to specific, actionable measures—helping you navigate finances, manage cross-border exposure, and access expert support, including Virtual CFO and valuation services. Stay tuned to learn how smart planning can help you face whatever comes next with confidence.

We are a boutique firm with a useful combination of more than 25 years of experience as a CFO and expert knowledge of valuations, corporate finance, data analytics and business models. Please contact us for 15-minute free consultation at sanjay@sankulinc.com or 647 297 7025. Please visit our websites: sankulinc.com and businessvaluegrowth.com

© 2025 [Sanjay Kulkarni, Sankul Enterprises Inc.]. All rights reserved. This article is protected under copyright laws. Unauthorized copying, reproduction, or distribution is strictly prohibited. For permissions, contact above.

Disclaimer:
The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, it may not apply to specific situations. Readers are encouraged to seek personalized advice from a qualified professional regarding their unique circumstances. The author and publisher accept no responsibility for any decisions made based on this content.